Home     Writers     Op/Ed     Book Reviews     News     Bookstore     Photoshops     Submit     Search     Contact Us     Advertise  
  You are here: 





The Inheritance – The World Obama Confronts and the Challenges to American Power. Book Review by Jim Miles
Monday, 03 August 2009 18:35
by Jim Miles

The Inheritance – The World Obama Confronts and the Challenges to American Power. David E. Sanger. Harmony Books (Random House), New York. 2009.

David Sanger makes it clear what his book, “The Inheritance”, is all about. Simply stated in the first line of the preface he says, “This book looks backward at the seismic events that led America to lose so much standing and leverage in the world and looks forward to reimagine ways we can rebuild our influence and power.” While the book itself makes for an interesting – but not enlightening – read, it does not do well with either looking backward or looking forward.


The look backward is essentially a look back at the Bush years, a commentary on current events as seen as a newspaper correspondent who has some kind of access, direct or indirect, to many of the higher officials in the administration. It does not go back far enough to cover important aspects of the pre-Bush history – a history that served as Bush’s “Inheritance” as well. In other words, U.S. history cannot be isolated to one era without fitting it into the overall context of its foreign and domestic policies that are intertwined into a much longer string of history. Certainly references are made to earlier historical moments, but there is little analysis, little context, and as with many U.S. writers, the context of “blowback” from previous negative U.S. policies is not truly accounted for. There is little acceptance of U.S. foreign policy practices that over the decades have helped shape the mess they currently find themselves in.


The problem with Sanger’s look forward is that there really is not one, certainly not on the scale of Stern’s “The Global Deal” or Starobin’s “After America”[1]. While I am not always a fan of conjecture into the future, as unintended and unexpected consequences tend to be the norm, there should be more room given to developing more ideas on how Obama could move forward to help untangle the current foreign policy difficulties. His look forward consists mainly of three short items, all really one and the same thing – a terrorist attack of some sort on the homeland, and one piece of advice.

The three items are familiar to anyone who reads any kind of newspaper or internet site with news on it: rogue nuclear weapons; chemical weapons in the form of plagues, toxins or poisons; and computer cyber-attack. This look forward occupies the last ninth of the book and consists mainly of scary scenarios from think tanks and the poor job the administration is doing to prevent any of them.

When Sanger talks about Obama in the Epilogue “Obama’s Challenge,” a meagre ten pages is devoted to Obama’s prospects for ‘change’. He quotes Rahm Emanuel who said, “Never allow a crisis to go to waste; they are opportunities to do big things.” The intent is to spur Obama to action. Unfortunately it fits into the general trend of U.S. history that a “crisis” includes the context of history, it also includes the creating and fomenting of a crisis that can be taken advantage of, a strong point of the CIA and special ops teams. Pakistan/Afghanistan and Iran are the current crises, treated by Sanger as special developments of the Bush era.


Four illusions from the Bush era face Obama, according to Sanger. The first is the shift of global power – more economic than military, but also including the latter - is heading east. The second illusion is that the rest of the world “will naturally seek to emulate the American model.” The other two illusions are smaller in scale. Free trade is not primarily responsible for job loss. The U.S. will no longer use the “Big Stick and no longer threaten force to contains some of the world’s biggest perils.”

These are not just Bush illusions, they are U.S. illusions and can be writ boldly. And illusory or not, Obama has not done much to dispel them and if he follows Sanger’s main line of advice, will only affirm the “illusions” in the minds of the citizens:

“Marry the use of force to a comprehensive plan to build up states, pursued with the same gusto and resources as Bush used to pursue al Queda cells.”

That about sums up the proposals for the future – marry force with state building plans and dispel a few illusions! Sounds pretty much like the same old Bush program, but as with all things Obama, it will probably be carried out with much finer sounding rhetoric than the gunslinger lingo that Bush employed.

Known and very popular cialis coupon which gives all the chance to receive a discount for a preparation which has to be available and exactly cialis coupons has been found in the distant room of this big house about which wood-grouses in the houses tell.

Missing in action

A reader interested in current events would do well with this work as it contains much of the history of the Bush administration, although without any great insights into any of it. What is missing for the reader is that historical string that entwines itself around all presidencies, as U.S. foreign policy, and while it may receive a different tone and timbre from one president to the next, always sings the same song.

The U.S. faces crises with Afghanistan, Pakistan, Iran for sure, crises that have a great deal to do with previous U.S. policies towards the region. Israel is mentioned within the context of Iran, but no mention of Palestine occurs. If the Middle East is to be “solved”, Palestine/Israel must be solved. If the Middle East is to be solved, the U.S. needs to account for much of its covert and overt operations there since essentially taking over from the British Empire.

Other omissions from action especially looking towards the future concern two major global crises, the economic meltdown and global climate change, neither of which receive any serious consideration. For that matter, it seems that the only seriousness about the solutions is the line about “force” and “gusto.”

If any of this is to be solved, not only the linear integration of historical information needs to be considered, but the multi-dimensional integration of a variety of concepts needs to be included. That includes the global and domestic economies, climate change, the role of international law and international institutions, the settlement of international disputes by applying international law and human rights agreements, the pervasiveness of U.S. military bases globally and its dominant nuclear weapons base, the many diverging foreign policy views from China, Russia, Japan, the Koreas and others, and especially the ongoing tactic of “force” and “gusto” used to ‘promote’ U.S. foreign policy – the hidden (not so hidden really) fist that supports the U.S. accumulation of wealth and power to the homeland.

Some Inheritance

Admittedly, Obama “inherited” a mess, but it is not a mess that he was unfamiliar with. Nor can anyone be elected president in the U.S. if they do not fit the general conforming modes of acceptable presidential practices. Nor should any reader be under any illusion that the mess was a result of the Bush administration, but is the ongoing familiar territory of U.S. foreign policy. Only six months into the Obama tenure, and there are very few signs of “hope” and “audacity” (attacking Pakistan and increasingly using Ms Clinton to spread U.S. threats around counts for neither).

All the same, “The Inheritance” provides a good enough read for a non-academic, not too critical audience to pick up on some current events information they may have missed out on during the Bush years. Just don’t expect any great pronouncements of solutions for the future.

[1] see Paul Starobin, “After America”, at http://www.palestinechronicle.com/view_article_details.php?id=15273; Nicholas Stern's book, "The Global Deal" (Public Affairs, Perseus, New York. 2009) is a flawed discussion of climate change and the economy.

- 30 -

Jim Miles is a Canadian educator and a regular contributor/columnist of opinion pieces and book reviews for The Palestine Chronicle. Miles’ work is also presented globally through other alternative websites and news publications.

More from this author:
Harper’s foreign policy of American convenience. (9960 Hits)
by Jim Miles Stephen Harper has been making much of himself lately, promoting his version of how to achieve global peace and prosperity,...
Canada - Time to exit NATO (6148 Hits)
by Jim Miles NATO has recently had one of its regular meetings of the “Military Committee” in Victoria, B.C., Canada, with...
It’s not about the Carbon (4807 Hits)
by Jim Miles While there are still many people debating whether or not global warming is occurring, or if it is caused by human factors or...
Uncertain outcomes –the Israeli-Palestine question (4694 Hits)
by Jim Miles After 9/11, 2001, when I first started examining the various landscapes – physical, political, cultural, military – of events...
Same old, same old Israel wins again (4779 Hits)
by Jim Miles As I sit and read the announcements from todays first discussions from Annapolis, all I can see is another dismal failure for peace...
Related Articles:
War in Heaven: Woodward's Book and the Establishment Insurgency (19116 Hits)
Bob Woodward has long been the voice of the American Establishment – or of certain quadrants of it, at any rate. When Richard Nixon's...
Some Things You Need To Know Before The World Ends (20783 Hits)
" Thank you for not putting a bomb in your luggage." "President Bush said the United States is still under the threat of attack ...
American Manifesto (13597 Hits)
Steve is a New Englander, an educated man. He's been released from jail just a few hours before the rendezvous with the camera, late at ... all »...
The Anti-Empire Report - Some things you need to know before the world ends (15409 Hits)
by William Blum The jingo bells are ringing "Who really poses the greatest danger to world peace: Iraq, North Korea or the United...
American Voters Must Not Reward Failure (14297 Hits)
By Ramzy Baroud How critical is the situation in Iraq? It depends on who you ask and when. Common sense tells us that the situation there...
Comments (0)add comment

Write comment
smaller | bigger



Top 123