Home     Writers     Op/Ed     Book Reviews     News     Bookstore     Photoshops     Submit     Search     Contact Us     Advertise  
  You are here: 

Sat

07

Feb

2009

SEC Negligence in Madoff Swindle Makes it Liable for Victim's Losses
Saturday, 07 February 2009 09:50
by Sherwood Ross

A Massachusetts law school dean that lost money invested with swindler Bernard Madoff said that the Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) was “willfully, horribly negligent” in failing to monitor his operation.

Lawrence Velvel, dean of the Massachusetts School of Law at Andover, said, “The SEC’s incredible willful negligence” to not seriously investigate Madoff’s operations despite repeated red flags and written warnings of his criminality probably makes the agency liable to legal action by aggrieved investors. The SEC, he said, “has no discretion—none—to fail to follow up, with serious investigations, when presented with knowledgeable, detailed, obviously highly competent, and in many respects easily ‘checkable’ allegations of...a huge fraud that is fooling thousands of people, stealing billions of dollars, and causing horrible injustice.”

Equally bad, says Velvel, the SEC was responsible for a lot of people being sucked into Madoff in the first place, because in 1992 it publicly announced that there was no fraud.

Referring to the preponderant majority of Madoff’s victims, Velvel said, “These are not the billionaires, or the huge institutions, that could hire expensive experts in due diligence…These are the plain people who worked hard and saved all their lives, as capitalism says they should, and who…depended on their government to protect them…but were failed by it because of one of the most willfully negligent, incompetent, and perhaps even complicitous courses of action any agency has ever engaged in.”

Velvel also said The Financial Industry Regulatory Authority (FINRA), a private organization of brokerage industry members supposedly dedicated to “investor protection and market integrity,” is also probably liable for damages. FINRA examined Madoff every two years from 1960 onwards, and in 2007 FINRA conducted a sloppy probe that concluded parts of Madoff’s operation had no customers when, in fact, it had thousands. What’s more, “If FINRA had so much as competently checked whether the company had the securities and money it claimed, it would have uncovered the fraud,” Velvel writes.

Velvel also says investors should not be required to return sums Madoff told them they had and which they innocently withdrew from Madoff to live on. “This is terrifying to people, and, rightly so. Having been wiped out . . . people now face the prospect of being obligated to give back six years of withdrawals — often withdrawals they needed to live, as with older people.” These people often have no money to give back.


Velvel is also critical of the fact that there is only a three year period for which Madoff investors can reclaim taxes they paid on “phantom income” — money Madoff falsely told them they had earned, so they paid taxes on it. He notes that when the IRS finds an individual guilty of tax fraud it can collect taxes going back 25 years or more because it had a right to the money. When it had no right to the money, the defrauded investor can only go back three years. So the IRS does not allow the same right to those defrauded that it claims for itself.

The SEC had been informed at least as far back as 1999 by investment professional Harry Markopolos, in a major study, that Madoff’s business “could not possibly be on the up and up,” Velvel says, and Markopolos kept reminding the agency periodically but to no avail. Again, the SEC was warned about Madoff in an article written in 2001 for the little known hedge fund-industry publication “MAR/Hedge” by reporter Michael Ocrant.

Finally, most investors knew nothing about a 2001 Barron’s article by reporter Erin Arvedlund “that focused on secrecy” by Madoff and that should have been a red flag to the SEC, yet the SEC did nothing. The SEC should also have tumbled to Madoff’s crimes, Velvel says, because he was handling many billions of other peoples’ money with a tiny, three-person auditor shop, only one of whom was an accountant, and because Madoff handled his own trades rather than have an independent firm make them, and did not use an independent custodian, both of which would have helped to ensure that the claimed securities and money existed. As it turned out, Madoff lied to investors about trades he was making in their behalf.

Velvel made his comments on his blog "Velvel on National Affairs" in a six-part series published Jan. 20-24. Velvel, a former U.S. Justice Department attorney, is co-founder and Dean of the Massachusetts School of Law at Andover and regarded as one of the nation's leaders in reforming the way legal education is taught and making quality legal education available to minorities and students from families of modest means.
More from this author:
Prevent Future Massacres by Curbing Bullying (9306 Hits)
by Sherwood Ross Society could reduce the number of senseless killings on campuses and in workplaces and shopping malls if it paid closer...
Bush Arms Dictators Around The World (8612 Hits)
by Sherwood Ross “In the last six years, Washington has stepped up its sales and transfers of high-technology weapons, military training, and...
CIA’S Overthrow of Iran in 1953 Reaps Bitter Harvest For America (8079 Hits)
by Sherwood Ross Iranians’ hatred of America dates back to the CIA’s violent 1953 overthrow of democratic Prime Minister Mohammed...
The Housing Bubble, Bailout, Good Jobs and Goodfellas (6909 Hits)
by Sherwood Ross The rush to bail out Wall Street is tragic. It’s as if the sun wouldn’t rise tomorrow unless Congress acted immediately....
The United States of England (10995 Hits)
by Sherwood Ross Why don’t we call America the United States of England? It may be a separate entity politically and geographically, but today...
Related Articles:
"Fast Food Nation" Makes Headlines (7259 Hits)
by Mickey Z. In almost every movie ever made, at some point, a character will consume animal products: a cheeseburger, a steak, a tuna...
Tony Blair Makes a Donation -- to a Government including an International Terrorist (7336 Hits)
by Winter Patriot Tony Blair went to Pakistan last weekend with a quarter of a billion pounds in his back pocket and high hopes of making a...
Bush makes a “Clean Break” with the Baker Plan (6495 Hits)
by Mike Whitney “Pressure from the Lobby was not the only factor behind the decision to attack Iraq in 2003, but it was critical. Some...
Congresswoman Cynthia McKinney Makes the Case for Impeachment (7840 Hits)
by David Swanson As some people learned from the minimal and abusive media coverage, on December 8, 2006, Congresswoman Cynthia McKinney...
It’s Got to Be Gore– Part IV: The Essential Quality that Makes Gore the Leader for These Times (4669 Hits)
by Andrew Bard Schmookler Over the weekend, a story posted on Huffington Post, and attributed to Agence France Press, quoted Al Gore as...


Add this page to your favorite Social Bookmarking websites
Trackback(0)
Comments (0)add comment

Write comment
smaller | bigger

busy
 

adsense

Top