Home     Writers     Op/Ed     Book Reviews     News     Bookstore     Photoshops     Submit     Search     Contact Us     Advertise  
  You are here: 

Thu

15

Apr

2010

Anna Baltzer on Being Jewish, Israeli, Zionist. Or Not.
Thursday, 15 April 2010 05:15
Transcript by Zahir Ebrahim, Video by Anna Baltzer

I am Anna Baltzer. My first reaction when I heard these things by the way was complete disbelief. I thought there is no way, there is no way that Israel is anything different from what I believe it to be, and what I know it to be. When I met people who told me anything different, I thought well these are perfectly nice people, but they have been brain washed. They have been told propaganda. And I set out to sort of try and prove them wrong. To show them that I knew what I was talking about.

And as soon as I began to do some research, I realized very quickly that I was the one who is missing a lot of information on this issue.  And not knowing sort of who to believe anymore, decided to go there and see with my own two eyes what was happening in Palestine.  So that's what I travel around the country telling people about is what I found there.

I hope I can offer people a combination of sort of some of the basics of what's going on there, and then also some ways of going a little bit deeper into the history, and most importantly, where we can go from here. I like like to start out by clarifying a few different categories that can be very confusing to people in addressing this issue. I'd like to distinguish between what it means to be Jewish: so I am Jewish what does that mean. Somebody who is Jewish is somebody either of the Jewish religion, obviously, or the Jewish lineage. My mother is Jewish, her mother is Jewish, etceteras. It's a bloodline.

And that to be Jewish is different from what it means to be Israeli: an Israeli is a citizenship, and Israeli is a citizen of the state of Israel.  And that to be Israeli is different from what it means to be a Zionist: Zionism is the political ideology that supports the idea of a Jewish state in historic Palestine, sometimes no matter what that means in reality, and no matter what it does.

Anyway, these are different categories, Jewish, Israeli, Zionist.  And sometimes they overlap in the same person, but they are not the same thing. There are Jews who are not Israeli, like myself. There are Israelis who aren't Jewish, about 25, about 20 percent of the Israeli population is Palestinian. There are Jews who are anti-Zionist, who say this land should be for anybody who's been living there for generations regardless of what their religion or their ethnicity is. And then there are Zionists who aren't Jewish. The increasingly influential Christian Zionist movement, largely based in this country that talks about fueling this conflict to bring about the Armageddon, the return of the Messiah. Again, not at all pro-Jewish, right? You know what happens to Jews in the Armageddon is not about preserving Judeism, it is Zionism.

So we see this distinction and it's very important that we see that distinction and that we express it when we are talking about this issue.  First of all, because there is no reason to associate anything that Israel is doing in terms of occupation, oppression, segregation, things that were pretty sobering that I found when I was over there. These things have nothing to do with Judeism.

And likewise, to speak out when we see people's rights being violated is not anti-Jewish.  It's not anti-Semitic. In fact, it's in line with the tradition of social justice that has been the pride of Jewish people as well as many other communities for a very long time.  So I wanna start out with that, especially because I know that people talking about this issue are often, sort of, these names are called at you, and it's absolutely absurd.  There is nothing Jewish about what Israel's doing, nothing anti-Jewish about speaking out when we see it happening.'

More from this author:
'Bin Laden': Key enabler of “imperial mobilization” (5747 Hits)
by Zahir Ebrahim Written April 17, 2008 - Updated April 22, 2008. The abominable shared fates that unite Iran (“Bush and Iran,...
From Balance of Terror to Unilateral Terror on the Grand Chessboard! (5904 Hits)
by Zahir Ebrahim Written April 26, 2008 - Revised May 2, 2008. Douglas J. Feith, Undersecretary of Defense for Policy, in his Hearing...
America’s Shame (4578 Hits)
by Zahir Ebrahim March 31, 2007: I wrote this essay as the Preface to "Prisoners of the Cave" during 2003. That was four years ago....
How to derail 'imperial mobilization' and preempt the crossing of the Nuclear Rubicon (4963 Hits)
by Zahir Ebrahim It appears that a majority of conscionable peoples opposed to their nation's war mongering for “imperial mobilization” in...
Someone's Holiday, Another's Nakba, Our Shame! (5778 Hits)
by Zahir Ebrahim Sunday April 06, 2008. It is à propos to begin this brief observation in 2008, on a cloudy Sunday morning while...
Related Articles:
Blogswarm in Action - KSFO Radio - Racist, Repugnant and now being Ravaged by the Blogosphere (8578 Hits)
Guest Article by Mike Stark Most of you know that Disney owns ABC. ABC, of course, owns the ABC Radio Network. Finally, ABCRN owns KSFO, a...
The Hypocritical Christian Right is being “Left Behind” (8179 Hits)
by Mel Seesholtz, Ph.D. Rev. Lonnie W. Latham was a fire and brimstone, Bible-thumping anti-gay Baptist pastor and member of the executive...
Waging Peace: Being at Peace (4415 Hits)
by ddjango In the Wikipedia, peace is defined as follows: Peace is a state of harmony, absent open hostility. This term is applied to...
Democrats, Stop Coddling The Children! STOP BEING SO DAMN FREAKING WEAK!! (4757 Hits)
by Linda Milazzo Democrats in Congress, this message is for YOU! There's a reason Republicans call Democrats weak. IT'S BECAUSE YOU DAMN...
Being Jose Padilla (5350 Hits)
by Jayne Lyn Stahl Now that a U.S. citizen has been convicted of being a "terrorist," one can only hope that his treatment in the...


Add this page to your favorite Social Bookmarking websites
Trackback(0)
Comments (0)add comment

Write comment
smaller | bigger

busy
 

adsense

Top