Home     Writers     Op/Ed     Book Reviews     News     Bookstore     Photoshops     Submit     Search     Contact Us     Advertise  
  You are here: 





American troops suffer hardships - American diplomats have inconveniences
Friday, 19 March 2010 06:55
by Matthew Nasuti

Since the publication of the article “American Diplomats Shun ‘Hardship Posts’ in the Third World,” this author has received some amazing feedback from former and current members of the American diplomatic community. They complain that they face real hardships living in diplomatic posts outside of Europe. Some of the comments are shocking, some are petty and silly, and some offers a window into a host of problems within the U.S. Department of State. Overall, the comments provide an unflattering insight into the usually secret world of American diplomats. We feel we have an obligation to share this information with our readers.

All the comments except one were sent anonymously to the author. The diplomats refused to disclose their identities apparently due to a fear of retaliation from the State Department for their dismal portrayals of life in the diplomatic service, or due to fear of negative public opinion due to the lack of respect some diplomats have for many foreign countries.

The first comments were posted on the American diplomatic blog: www.lifeafterjerusalem.blogs.. .. The writer claims to have been an American diplomat assigned to Jerusalem. He asserts that it was a true hardship to be posted in Jerusalem. He writes:

“The people who live in Jerusalem are not the secular Jews and Arabs of Tel Aviv.”

The idea that there are two kinds of Jews and Arabs, and that one kind lives in Tel Aviv and the other kind lives in Jerusalem is absurd. Also this particular diplomat apparently believes that there are good Jews and bad Jews. Apparently a “good Jew” is secular and non-religious. Likewise the writer apparently considers a “good Arab” to be secular and someone who should be living in Tel Aviv.

Known and very popular cialis coupon which gives all the chance to receive a discount for a preparation which has to be available and exactly cialis coupons has been found in the distant room of this big house about which wood-grouses in the houses tell.

The refusal of the American diplomatic community to criticize comments such as this fosters a continuing perception that is a strong anti-Israel, anti-Islam viewpoint within the State Department. This author, as a former State Department official, can attest that there is an anti-religious viewpoint held by some within the State Department. They view religion as a barrier to business deals and political settlements, rather than recognizing religion for its core and fundamental importance to many people. These diplomats feel that if they relegate a country’s religion to the status of a sideline distraction, they do not have to study and understand that religion; they only have to pay lip service to it in occasional speeches.

This author received comments from an American diplomat who had been posted to Guinea. He agreed that his family lived better than “99.9% of the people of Guinea” but he still considered it a hardship to live in Guinea.

One diplomat’s wife wrote of how dangerous it was to live in Moscow during the phase when Chechen rebels were setting off bombs. This author does not doubt that danger, but again it has nothing to do with why Moscow is a hardship post. The State Department separately determines countries to be (1) dangerous (2) overly expensive and (3) hardship. This author’s article dealt only with the last category. He agrees with the premise that the first two categories may be legitimate.

Another diplomat wrote of the dangers of his posting in Nepal. As Nepal is a favorite vacation spot for many people, the dangers may have been exaggerated. Regardless, whether a particular country is dangerous and merits dispensing danger pay, has nothing to do with whether the country is a hardship post which merits hardship pay. None of these diplomats seem to understand the difference between danger pay and hardship pay.

Generally, diplomat wives wrote about the disruptive effects of having to uproot their families every two years. They considered this to be a generic hardship, despite the fact that it is part of the job they signed on for. One commented that every two years she has to learn how to shop for groceries in a different language. She fails to understand that such shopping should be fun, not a hardship. This author has campaigned for the United State to reduce its rotations and keep diplomats in each country 3-4 years at least. It is expensive and counter-productive to move tens of thousands of diplomats and their families every 1-2 years to a new country.

One diplomat did have a very moving story about his dog who had contracted a parasitic skin infection and could not get any treatment in the host country. The United States barred the pet from returning to America for treatment so it died a long and painful death overseas. That story is not a hardship. The U.S. Ambassador should have called whomever he or she had to, up to and including the President of the United States and gotten a waiver from the Department of Agriculture so that the dog could be returned to the United States for treatment. That dog died due to bureaucratic incompetence and that death should never have happened. That diplomat should convey all the facts to the Kabul Press and should include the name of the Ambassador and anyone else who refused to help the dog. This author would be happy to publicize their misconduct and push for the State Department to adopt rules to protect diplomatic pets.
Daniel Hirsch is the Vice-President of the State Department’s American Foreign Service Association. He commented on the Kabul Press article but his comments were disappointing because he failed to address the core elements of the story, which are:

(1) Repeated government audits have found that many American diplomats do not have the language skills that they need for the countries in which they are posted; and
(2) Many diplomatic posts in U.S. Embassies in the developing world are not being filled as diplomats refuse to volunteer for them.

The conclusion drawn from these two findings is that American foreign policy and therefore American national security is being negatively impacted by these diplomatic shortcomings.

In addition, Mr. Hirsch did not explain why most non-European, non-white countries have been designated as “hardship posts” for American diplomats. While it is undisputed that some countries are more difficult to live in than others; all of the countries which the State Department has designated as a hardship, are not. It is offensive to label them all as such.

Mr. Hirsch did not comment on our prior articles where we criticized the American Embassies in Baghdad and Kabul for obtaining an exemption so that their diplomats can drink alcohol and party. As he knows, the American military has banned the consumption of alcohol for all military personnel deployed in Iraq and Afghanistan, but the U.S. State Department insists that its diplomats are in hardship posts and they need the crutch of alcohol to get them through the day. If anyone should be entitled to have a beer at the end of the day it is the troops in combat, not the diplomats sitting in their offices.

The U.S. Veterans Administration has treated more than 400,000 veterans over the past nine years for traumatic brain injuries, battle fatigue, permanent hearing damage, back injuries, diseases and other problems, in addition to those wounded due to ballistic or blast injuries as a result of their service in Iraq and Afghanistan.

American troops in the field are enduring hardships; State Department diplomats, for the most part, simply have some inconveniences.

If Mr. Hirsch wants to help diplomatic families in some countries, he should lobby Secretary of State Hillary Clinton to put off her lavish new $1 billion embassy in London and spend that money to improve housing and commissary facilities at diplomatic posts.

If he believes that diplomats still need extra money, he should push to have such funds re-designated. He should make up a vague label for the funds, perhaps calling them “X-37b allotments,” instead of “hardship pay.” We should not be designating any country as a hardship. The first rule of diplomacy is: Try not to offend anyone if you do not have to.
More from this author:
America’s "Phantom Aid" to Afghanistan (6422 Hits)
by Matthew Nasuti Reuters reported on April 23, 2007 that Peter Bergen, a senior fellow at the New America Foundation, had testified before the...
U.S. Embassy Gambles Away Afghanistan Aid Funds (9414 Hits)
by Matthew Nasuti The U.S. Embassy in Kabul usually wastes Afghan aid funds on a grand scale, but the Kabul Press has discovered that it is...
America’s happy war in Afghanistan - American government sugar-coating Afghan war news for sweet-toothed U.S. media (8946 Hits)
by Matthew Nasuti. America reigns supreme in Afghanistan in air power and in its own press releases. Western press offices are surging...
America’s happy war in Afghanistan - American government sugar-coating Afghan war news for sweet-toothed U.S. media (6867 Hits)
by Matthew Nasuti. America reigns supreme in Afghanistan in air power and in its own press releases. Western press offices are surging...
Building Junk Schools in Afghanistan (8895 Hits)
by Matthew Nasuti U.S. Military falsifies completion of Farukh Shah School. Every building in the school complex has serious structural...
Related Articles:
Why does Thailand have all the Luck? (11037 Hits)
About 2 weeks ago, 10 Soviet-era tanks clanked-along the main thoroughfare in downtown Bangkok and stopped in front of the Presidential Palace. Once...
American Manifesto (12547 Hits)
Steve is a New Englander, an educated man. He's been released from jail just a few hours before the rendezvous with the camera, late at ... all »...
American Voters Must Not Reward Failure (13152 Hits)
By Ramzy Baroud How critical is the situation in Iraq? It depends on who you ask and when. Common sense tells us that the situation there...
US-Latin American Relations: Ruptures, Reaction and the Times of the Past (15501 Hits)
by James Petras Introduction Numerous writers, journalists, public officials and academics on the Right and Left have noted changes in...
Baghdad is Surrounded: “The American Era in the Middle East has ended” (10654 Hits)
by Mike Whitney   Don Rumsfeld is not a good leader. In fact, he is a very bad leader. Leadership is predicated on three basic factors:...

Add this page to your favorite Social Bookmarking websites
Comments (3)add comment

Brian Dear said:

You said, "As Nepal is a favorite vacation spot for many people, the dangers may have been exaggerated." Are you that ignorant? Maoist rebels have been active in Nepal for years and violence is a regular occurrence. Nepal isn't a vacation spot in a traditional sense. It's dirty, dangerous and, when you're representing the US government, you aren't a tourist -- you're a target. Perhaps you ought to live there for 3 years, then come back and try and report something factual rather than just opinion based on reading Lonely Planet.
March 22, 2010
Votes: +0

Matt Nasuti said:

To: Brian
If some people in Nepal disliked you when you were there, I can completely understand them. I have only known you a few seconds and you do not seem very likable. If you believe that the developing world is dirty and dangerous, then move to Kansas and live there. Even if you disliked your tour in Nepal, it is unprofessional to sound off about it in a public blog. You are supposed to be representing the United States. Nepal is a friend of the United States. Please keep any negative comments about another country in-house. Thank you.
March 22, 2010
Votes: +0

... said:

Good lord man, you're a horrible writer. I'm not even talking about the content, just the logic flow (or lack thereof) you attempt to present.

As for the actual content.........rubbish, as well. "She fails to understand that such shopping should be fun, not a hardship" ...I laugh.
April 01, 2010
Votes: +0

Write comment
smaller | bigger



Top 123