Home     Writers     Op/Ed     Book Reviews     News     Bookstore     Photoshops     Submit     Search     Contact Us     Advertise  
  You are here: 

Sat

17

Oct

2009

Constitutional Hypocrisy
Saturday, 17 October 2009 14:55
by Joel S. Hirschhorn

 

Millions of Americans are politically informed, smart, active and angry.  They see many wrongs in our political and government system.  They are fed up with politics as usual, meaning corrosive corruption of politicians by corporate and other special interests.  They see little good in either the Democrat or Republican parties.  And they almost always share a common bond: They love and honor the US Constitution, even though they may see some flaws in it.  Yet they are also constitutional hypocrites.

 

Why do I say this?  Because Americans are overwhelmingly ignorant or misinformed about the constitutional paths for amending the Constitution.  Too many, in fact, seem to miss the profoundly important point that the Founders and Framers knew that they had not created a perfect document and blueprint for the US.  That is why they placed two specific paths for amending the Constitution.

 

But very few Americans know that only one of these amendment mechanisms has been used in the entire history of the country.  All the current amendments were proposed by Congress.  This should raise this serious question today: Considering the very low regard for Congress by the overwhelming majority of Americans, which is richly deserved, why should we have any confidence that Congress would ever propose amendments that could kill so much of the corruption that plagues our system, especially corruption of members of Congress?

 

This situation was somehow anticipated by the Framers.  They could see that there was a strong possibility that Americans would eventually lose confidence in the federal government.  Which is why they put a second path to amending the Constitution into the document.  A path that has never been used.  This is the provision in Article V for a convention of state delegates that could propose amendments, which like the proposals from Congress would still have to be ratified by three-quarters of the states.
 

 

Being human, the Framers made a mistake.  They gave Congress the sole power to call or convene an Article V convention.  The single explicit requirement that was supposed to make Congress call a convention was that two-thirds of state legislatures had to request an Article V convention.  The Framers did not, apparently, envision a future in which Congress would stubbornly ignore state applications for a convention and get away with it, despite language that demands that Congress “shall” call a convention when one simple requirement is met.  How could they envision that Congress would blatantly disobey something so simply stated in the Constitution?  How could they anticipate such weak states, unwilling to make Congress respect their constitutional right?  The Framers clearly were not cynical enough.

 

The situation we face today is that all 50 states have submitted over 750 applications for a convention, considerably more than enough to trigger the constitutional mandate that Congress convene an Article V convention.  How could Congress get away with this kind of unconstitutional behavior?  Apparently, a combination of political corruption and public ignorance has allowed Congress to get away with this.  Even among the millions of Americans that proudly declare their loyal allegiance to the Constitution, there is no recognition that unless they demand that Congress obey Article V, they are constitutional hypocrites.  Congress has no right to unilaterally decide that it can ignore and disobey a part of the Constitution.

 

Note that Congress never even created a mechanism where they would collect in a public way the state applications for an Article V convention, which helped create public ignorance of this situation.  Add to this that many, many organized vested interests on the left and right like their ability to corrupt Congress to get what they want from it.  This is why they have frequently mounted campaigns to make the public fear a convention, because such a convention might actually propose reforms that would remove corruption of Congress by contributing money for campaigns and pursuing lobbying.

 

Ignorance and fear have combined to thwart public demands that Congress obey the Constitution and convene the first Article V convention.  In fact, there is only one national, nonpartisan organization vainly attempting to educate the public so that Congress would be forced to finally give us the first Article V convention.  Friends of the Article V Convention at foavc.org is also the only group that has collected state applications for a convention and made them publicly available.

 

Their efforts may be working.  A new online survey asked this: Based on your assessment of American politics, would you support or oppose a call for a Constitutional Convention?  Supporters won easily at 65 percent.

 

It comes down to this, unless you get informed and join the mission to make Congress obey the Constitution, you are a constitutional hypocrite, not what the nation needs.

 

[Contact Dr. Hirschhorn, a co-founder of FOAVC, through delusionaldemocracy.com]

 
More from this author:
Field of Screams - The Real Election Winners and Losers (8386 Hits)
by Joel S. Hirschhorn Forget political correctness. The revolution has NOT arrived! Bush is still president. The...
Direct Democracy Lost in Florida and Colorado (8350 Hits)
by Joel S. Hirschhorn With all the hoopla about the big Democratic win, little attention has been given to the assault on direct democracy....
Third Parties Fight for American Democracy (8524 Hits)
by Joel S. Hirschhorn A great democracy offers citizens sharp political choices. That’s what gives political freedom meaning. With ...
Honest Centrism for Populist Democracy (9343 Hits)
by Joel S. Hirschhorn The United States has lost its center through destructive centrifugal politics. America seems spinning out of control....
Economic Apartheid Kills (8508 Hits)
by Joel S. Hirschhorn To be successful in overturning our elitist plutocratic system we should add economic apartheid to our...
Related Articles:
Let It Come Down: Forcing the Constitutional Crisis of Liberty (7913 Hits)
Nat Hentoff, one of our great champions of civil liberties, uncovers the ugly truths behind the Bush Regime's plans for a Nuremberg-in-reverse at the...
Holiday Hypocrisy (6052 Hits)
by Stephen Lendman Borrowing the line from Gilbert & Sullivan's HMS Pinafore: "Things are seldom as they seem, Skim milk ...
Bush Dodges a Constitutional Bullet in New Mexico (5056 Hits)
by Dave Lindorff President Bush dodged a Constitutional bullet in New Mexico Thursday, when nine Democrats in the state senate joined all...
Conyers is my Constitutional Hero (4636 Hits)
by Dave Lindorff When it comes to defending the Constitution from the saboteurs of freedom and democracy in the Bush administration, my ...
Independence Day Hypocrisy (8294 Hits)
by Stephen Lendman Along with Christmas, no federal holiday is more celebrated than the day a new nation declared its independence from the ...


Add this page to your favorite Social Bookmarking websites
Trackback(0)
Comments (0)add comment

Write comment
smaller | bigger

busy
 

adsense

Top