Home     Writers     Op/Ed     Book Reviews     News     Bookstore     Photoshops     Submit     Search     Contact Us     Advertise  
  You are here: 

Wed

24

Jan

2007

Meat-eater's State of "The Nation"
Wednesday, 24 January 2007 12:20
by Mickey Z.

The (so-called) alternative press rarely "gets" vegetarianism, animal rights, and related issues. Case in point: The February 5, 2007 issue of The Nation featured a book review by Daniel Lazare called "My Beef With Vegetarianism." The book in question was 'The Bloodless Revolution' by Tristram Stuart (full disclosure: I have not read Stuart's book).

The "review" reads like a personal vendetta against those who choose a plant-based diet as Lazare dedicates as much space to his own opinions as those of author Stuart. "My Beef With Vegetarianism" also includes a wide range of uninformed assertions. For Lazare, death at a slaughterhouse involves merely "dispatching" the animal "quickly and efficiently" for the "good utilitarian purpose of feeding the hungry." He also engages in Fox News-level mind games with questions like: "If life is the highest value and taking it is never, ever permissible, then what are we to do in the case of a poisonous snake that is about to strike a sleeping infant?"

I'm wondering: Did a vegetarian spokesperson decree that taking a life is never permissible? Plus, we don't need imaginary examples like snakes and infants. The animals being slaughtered on a massive scale are not threatening anyone or anything, they do not die "quickly and efficiently," and the hungry are not being fed as a result of their grisly deaths.

Lazare dusts off another line of "reasoning" one might expect from a 12-year-old: "Cruel as it is to kill an ox or a pig, nature is even crueler. A tiger or wolf does not knock its prey senseless with a single blow to the forehead and then painlessly slit its jugular; rather, it tears it to pieces with its teeth." Lazare not only embarrasses himself with an absurd comparison, he yet again diminishes the horror and cruelty of the slaughter industry.

The ham-fisted Lazare forges on with his transparent agenda. Leonardo da Vinci didn't speak out against cruelty to animals, he "ranted" against it. Descartes' alleged "fruit-and-vegetable diet" may have contributed to his death at the relatively young age of 54. Vegetarianism's "dramatic resurgence in recent years" is thanks to "pierced and tattooed twentysomethings." Lazare erroneously‹yet predictably‹reports that Adolf Hitler was a "dedicated vegetarian," and goes on to enlighten his readers about what "most likely" drew Nazi dictator to vegetarianism: "its antihumanist and authoritarian elements." As if this were documented fact, no further elucidation is provided.

Speaking of ill-informed assumptions piled atop clumsy inaccuracies, Lazare also states: "More people are living better and eating more richly than anyone in the 1700s would have thought possible." Tell that to the one billion who live on less than one dollar a day and, by the way, how exactly do we know what "anyone in the 1700s" thought possible in this realm? Regardless, Lazare declares that scarcity "no longer serves as an argument for vegetarianism, and neither, for that matter, does health." For him, to consume animal flesh is to celebrate "humanity's ongoing struggle to create abundance out of scarcity." To do otherwise would be to wallow in "the silly defeatism of a diet of tofu and sprouts."

Ultimately, Lazare's "review" is nothing new and opinions similar to his are available widely...via the corporate media. On the other hand, an effectively functioning alternative media should be giving voice to opinions and ideas neglected by the mainstream.

Mickey Z. can be found on the Web at http://www.mickeyz.net.
More from this author:
Who killed Michael Moore? (Why and what's the reason for?) (11142 Hits)
(Inspired by the recent assassination of Russian journalist Anna Politkovskaya) There's no shortage of outrage on the Left. Plenty...
"Boiling Point" - Eroding Freedom: From John Adams to George W. Bush (13609 Hits)
Put a frog into a pot of boiling water, the well-known parable begins, and out that frog will jump to escape the obvious danger. Put that same...
Read This Before You Vote (12146 Hits)
If one were to believe the hype, nothing less than the fate the civilized world is riding on the results of the upcoming midterm elections....
Nukes: Iran and North Korea are not the problem (14006 Hits)
by Mickey Z. Thanks to the nuclear aspirations of North Korea and Iran, there's no shortage of rhetoric along these lines: "We can't let...
When "anti-war" doesn't mean anti-war (6473 Hits)
by Mickey Z. A casual stroll through most major U.S. cities would provide ample opportunity to encounter numerous stickers, buttons,...
Related Articles:
The Real Axis of Evil - A State without Mercy (12503 Hits)
by William A. Cook “And they bend their tongues like their bow for lies: but they are not valiant for the truth upon the earth; for they...
"Fast Food Nation" Makes Headlines (7267 Hits)
by Mickey Z. In almost every movie ever made, at some point, a character will consume animal products: a cheeseburger, a steak, a tuna...
Bush and the F-word in 2006: Police State or Progressivism in 2007? (8313 Hits)
by Heather Wokusch "Fascism should more appropriately be called Corporatism because it is a merger of state and corporate power." ...
An Open Letter to "The Decider" (5944 Hits)
by Jayne Lyn Stahl While the odds are probably better of getting a response from Santa, there are a few things I'd like to say if you can...
"The Involuntary Guest Worker Program" - America's Middle Passage Into the 21st Century (8827 Hits)
by Mark W. Bradley I promised myself I would listen to Tuesday night's “State of the Union” speech with an open mind, and I must now...


Add this page to your favorite Social Bookmarking websites
Trackback(0)
Comments (1)add comment

a guest said:

0
...
wow i did not know that
 
February 27, 2007
Votes: +0

Write comment
smaller | bigger

busy
 

adsense

Top