Home     Writers     Op/Ed     Book Reviews     News     Bookstore     Photoshops     Submit     Search     Contact Us     Advertise  
  You are here: 

Tue

28

Oct

2008

Gilad Atzmon - Tractatus Logico Palestinicus
Tuesday, 28 October 2008 09:35
by Gilad Atzmon

Atzmon tries to lift the Palestinian Discourse where Wittgenstein left it…

1 “What can be said at all can be said clearly, and what we cannot talk about, we must pass over in silence.” (Ludwig Wittgenstein 1918)

1.1 Humanism and ethics are ends worth fighting for.

1.2 Western politics and political discourse (on the other hand) are concerned with power and hegemony.

1.3 Hence, humanism and ethics are foreign to the Western political discourse and vice versa.

2 The Palestinian liberation struggle is grounded on humanist and ethical arguments since it is based on moral rights, namely ‘the right of return’ and ‘liberation’.

2.1 Since the Palestinian liberation struggle is a humanist cause, Western politicians and political discourse are foreign to the Palestinian struggle.

2.11 As a result Western politics left, right and centre were not able to provide for the Palestinian people and their struggle over the period of decades of Zionist abuse.

2.12 This is unfortunately a true reading of the colossal failure of the left in helping the Palestinian people. Being a political discourse, the left is concerned with power and hegemony. Consequently it had been exploiting the Palestinian discourse in order to maintain its own political relevance (or rather irrelevance) within its imaginary universe.

2.121 Palestinians have learned their lesson. Their liberation movement has matured and abandoned the utopian dream that was misleading and foreign to their national cause.

2.1211 Since the Palestinian struggle is a geographically orientated, ethnic and national struggle, proletarian, cosmopolitan ideologies better revise accordingly.

2.122 However, truth must be said. Western leftist campaigners were very effective in producing solidarity culture, whether these are badges, scarves and placards, which they circulated among themselves and to close family members.

2.123 And yet, badges, placards and flyers didn’t save a single Palestinian kid from being shelled by an Israeli tank.

2.2 The Palestinian people will have to liberate themselves.

2.21 And the solidarity activists had better learn to listen.

3 Since ‘humanism and ethics are worth fighting for’ (1.1),

3.1 And the Palestinian struggle is a human cause (2.1),

3.2 We must support the Palestinians for what they are and their (democratic) choice.

4 There is an inherent difficulty within the heart of the Palestinian solidarity discourse that must be addressed:

Zionism (ideology), Judaism (religion), Jewishness (identity) and the Jews (people) are closely related, confusing terms. Consequently, any form of pro-Palestinian activism is curtailed by the fear of accusations of sustaining ideas that may be considered by some as racism.

4.01 At the same time, the vast majority of the Palestinians and solidarity activists realise that Israel, Jewish lobbies, Jewish pressure groups and any other form of Jewish tribal activism are often indistinguishable.

4.1 The question that comes to mind is: how can we say what we believe to be the truth and still regard ourselves as humanists?

4.12 How can we talk openly about the Jewish state, Jewish lobbying, Judaism and Jewishness and still maintain an anti-racist humanist and ethical stand?

4.2 The answer is simple. We can do so only if we manage to categorically dismantle the traces of any racial argument. We must refrain from talking about the people yet attacking any form of Zionism, Jewish political tribalism and Jewishness. We must attack it as an ideology and as a dogmatic credo.

4.3 We are entitled to do so as humanists due to the simple reason that every form of Jewish tribal politics is racially orientated and exclusivist. We are entitled to refer to Jewish political tribalism as a non-humanist and anti-universalist worldview.

4.4 Consequently, dismantling Jewish ideology and political tribalism is a humanist task.

4.5 Fighting Jewish tribal politics is a humanist and ethical act because it aims toward peace, universalism and inclusiveness (as opposed to war, tribalism and exclusiveness).

5 “What can be said at all can be said clearly, and what we cannot talk about, we must pass over in silence.”
More from this author:
Congratulations Barak, congratulations Americans (6079 Hits)
by Gilad Atzmon Once again America has proven that it can bring a change about. In fact, I would not count on Obama himself to bring a real...
Sabra, Shatila and Collective Amnesia (5594 Hits)
by Gilad Atzmon Waltz With Bashir is a breath-taking new Israeli film, an animated documentary directed by Ari Folman. In ...
The Lady Between the Queen and the Tribe (5942 Hits)
by Gilad Atzmon In spite of the fact that I monitor Israeli press and Jewish activism on a daily basis, I must admit that almost once a day I...
Fighting Within - Gilad Atzmon Interviews Sid Shniad (IJV Canada) (5734 Hits)
by Gilad Atzmon Recently I have been corresponding with Sid Shniad (1), a founding member of Canadian Independent Jewish Voice (Canadian IJV) (2)....
Gilad Atzmon - Eine Kleine Nacht Murder: How Israeli Leaders Kill for their People's Votes (3463 Hits)
by Gilad Atzmon In order to grasp the latest devastating murderous Israeli expedition in Gaza one must deeply comprehend the Israeli identity...
Related Articles:
Fighting Within - Gilad Atzmon Interviews Sid Shniad (IJV Canada) (5734 Hits)
by Gilad Atzmon Recently I have been corresponding with Sid Shniad (1), a founding member of Canadian Independent Jewish Voice (Canadian IJV) (2)....
Gilad Atzmon - Eine Kleine Nacht Murder: How Israeli Leaders Kill for their People's Votes (3463 Hits)
by Gilad Atzmon In order to grasp the latest devastating murderous Israeli expedition in Gaza one must deeply comprehend the Israeli identity...
Gilad Atzmon - Living on Borrowed Time in a Stolen Land (3366 Hits)
by Gilad Atzmon Communicating with Israelis may leave one bewildered. Even now when the Israeli Air Force is practicing murder in broad...
Gilad Atzmon - Board of Deputies of British Jews: on the road to nowhere (5804 Hits)
by Gilad Atzmon Yesterday evening I was informed about an email notification from the most rabid Zionist institutes operating in Britain, The...
Gilad Atzmon - Israel Has Managed to Lose Again (2552 Hits)
by Gilad Atzmon Haaretz reported today that IDF Senior officials "believe that Israel should strive to reach an immediate cease-fire with Hamas,...


Add this page to your favorite Social Bookmarking websites
Trackback(0)
Comments (2)add comment

test said:

0
test
test test test one two three
 
October 28, 2008 | url
Votes: +0

Lou Holloway said:

0
...
I agree with the essence of this argument, particularly the assertion that any fight should be grounded specifically on humanist and ethical premises with a view to avoiding the conflation of Israel (state) and Zionism (ideology) with Jews (people). It would benefit us all if moral arguments were more often framed in such a coherent and rational fashion.

I have two issues:

"1.1 Humanism and ethics are ends worth fighting for."

Is there a calculus which will determine the value of the term 'fighting' given the ends stated, and does that value vary given particular instances of those ends?

"1.2 Western politics and political discourse (on the other hand) are concerned with power and hegemony."
"2.1 Since the Palestinian liberation struggle is a humanist cause, Western politicians and political discourse are foreign to the Palestinian struggle."

While this is certainly true a lot of the time, and is certainly true of the majority of Western politics as practised by state bodies, it does not constitute an accurate summation of western political discourse, in as much as the terms 'ethics' and 'humanism' are quite often used within that discourse. I would argue that a 'soldarity activist' forged within this discourse might (possibly) formulate an opinion or a course of action based in these concerns, and further that 'power and hegemony' are crucial aspects of any ralationship between a state and a group of people.
 
April 23, 2009
Votes: +0

Write comment
smaller | bigger

busy
 

adsense

Top