Home     Writers     Op/Ed     Book Reviews     News     Bookstore     Photoshops     Submit     Search     Contact Us     Advertise  
  You are here: 

Thu

14

Jun

2007

A Civil War? Maybe We Have It Backwards Two Ways
Thursday, 14 June 2007 22:32
by Dal LaMagna

I've been in the Middle East for 10 days now, first in Amman, Jordan and now in Baghdad.  My goal is to hear what a variety of Iraqis have to say about how best to end this occupation and bring their voices to others.  That said, here's a recounting of a conversation I had with prominent Shiite cleric, Jawad al-Khalisi. We spoke about the current violence and what believes would happen in American forces pulled out.

I was startled when Sheik Jawad Al-Khalisi told me that there would be civil war in Iraq not if the American troops leave but if they stay!
 
I wasn’t sure I heard him correctly.
 
“If the Americans forces leave, are you saying there will be no civil war?” 
“Yes,” he said. 
I pressed him then, because many Iraqis I have listened to say that if our troops leave suddenly, a civil war could result. 

Potential for Civil War

I rephrased my question, wanting to make sure I understood. 
“If the American Forces leave suddenly, there will there be a Civil War. Is that what you are saying?” 
Jawad said: 
“The disorganized withdrawal and sudden withdrawal may lead to chaos and civil war because of the militias.” 
However, he also added that if American troops remain in Iraq, there presence would definitely lead to civil war and the American Army would be in the middle of it.
 
Our conversation continued (see the detailed transcript).  As he spoke, I listened and asked more questions.
 
It seemed that he was saying the current violence in Iraq is the result of a political war between those who want to divide Iraq and those who want a unified Iraq.  Americans may see it as a prelude to a sectarian civil war, but al-Khalisi was adamant that such was not the case.

Do We Have It Backwards?

So, perhaps we have it backwards two ways.
 
First:  We think that the strife in Iraq is sectarian, based on religious friction and factions.  But, according to Sheik Jawad Al-Khalisi that isn’t true, and it’s all about politics and whether to partition the country or keep it whole.

Second: We think that if our troops leave, the violence will increase, a sectarian civil war would break out and possibly spread through the Middle East.
 
During my time in Iraq, I hope to listen more, to see first hand what is going on, to learn what might and might not work, and hear from as many perspectives as I possibly can.
 

 
 
 
More from this author:
"Now Is an Opportune Time," Says a Member of Iraq's Parliament (2438 Hits)
by Dal LaMagna A five-minute monologue by one member of the Iraq Parliament, a member of the National Dialogue Front, sums up what several other...
Reality in Baghdad (2877 Hits)
by Dal LaMagna Going into a war zone for the first time is seldom what one expects, I imagine. I'm not quite sure what I had envisioned, but the...
Meeting with General Petraeus (3138 Hits)
by Dal LaMagna While in Baghdad, seeking ways to end the violence there, I met with General David Petraeus, the commanding general of the...
Meeting with Ambassador Margaret Scobey (3878 Hits)
by Dal LaMagna Ambassador Margaret Scobey has been on special assignment to Iraq for a year. In two weeks her mission is complete and...
Related Articles:
Why does Thailand have all the Luck? (9183 Hits)
About 2 weeks ago, 10 Soviet-era tanks clanked-along the main thoroughfare in downtown Bangkok and stopped in front of the Presidential Palace. Once...
Swing Blades: Don Rumsfeld Bats Both Ways (12351 Hits)
In February 2003, I wrote a column for the Moscow Times detailing Don Rumsfeld's personal – and profitable – connection with North Korea's...
Civil War in Iraq: The Salvador Option and US/UK Policy (9548 Hits)
by Craig Murray, As the catastrophe in Iraq continues to unfold, an unresolved question remains on the role of Bush, Blair, and the US/UK...
Have We Been Fooled Again? (7752 Hits)
By Tom Chartier These are the days of large, desperate measures.This is the era ofdictators, threats and wars.Unmodified by...
The Alleged "Liquid Bombing" Plot Revisited -- Maybe It Was Possible After All (8392 Hits)
by Winter Patriot As described in media reports of the day, the alleged "liquid bombing" plot which was allegedly foiled during the...


Add this page to your favorite Social Bookmarking websites
Trackback(0)
Comments (0)add comment

Write comment
smaller | bigger

busy
 

adsense

Top