Home     Writers     Op/Ed     Book Reviews     News     Bookstore     Photoshops     Submit     Search     Contact Us     Advertise  
  You are here: 

Thu

22

Feb

2007

Exquisite Corpus: Judges Junk Great Writ for Bush's Gulag
Thursday, 22 February 2007 18:04
by Chris Floyd

Guantanamo Detainees Lose Appeal (Washington Post)
A federal appeals court ruled yesterday that hundreds of detainees in U.S. custody at Guantanamo Bay, Cuba, do not have the right to challenge their imprisonment in federal courts, a victory for the Bush administration that could lead to the Supreme Court again addressing the issue.

In its 2 to 1 decision, the U.S. Court of Appeals for the District of Columbia Circuit upheld one of the central components of the Military Commissions Act, the law enacted last year by a then-Republican-controlled Congress that stripped Guantanamo detainees of their right to such habeas corpus petitions. Lawyers have filed the petitions on behalf of virtually all of the nearly 400 detainees still at Guantanamo, challenging President Bush's right to hold them indefinitely without charges. Yesterday's ruling effectively dismisses the cases.

This decision was of course rendered by a conservative-leaning court, and co-written by Judge David Sentelle, a right-wing hatchet man who has toted water for the Bush Faction and other right-wing authoritarians for many years. Sentelle, pictured right, was part of the panel picked by right-wing apparatchik William Rehnquist that removed Whitewater investigator Robert Fiske when he was about to clear the Clintons on the failed land deal case, and replace him with Kenneth Starr and his merry band of sexual obsessives.

Sentelle also voted to overturn the convictions of Iran-Contra scamsters Oliver North and John Poindexter for their roles in supplying guns to the Shiite extremist regime in Iran and funneling money to the terrorist Contra army in Nicaragua. Sentelle, a Reagan appointee, can always be counted on to approve any extension of arbitrary power by a Republican president. What's more, his partner in the majority, A. Raymond Randolph, was appointed by Daddy Bush. So there's nothing surprising about this court ruling in favor of draconian sway for the Bush Administration.

The twist in this case is that despite the clear ideological bias of the judges – especially Sentelle – they are correct on one essential point: allowing the detainees in Bush's gulag limbo to challenge their indefinite, uncharged imprisonment in federal court would indeed "defy the will of Congress." That's because last year the lockstep, rubberstamp, Reichstag Republicans pushed through the shameful "Military Commissions Act" (MCA) that openly accepted the principle that the "unitary executive" is beyond the reach of the law, and can strip the judiciary of its Constitutional role and set up kangaroo courts to try his captives as he pleases – or let them rot without trial for as long as he likes. Such a craven surrender to authoritarian rule was indeed the expressed will of the majority Reichstaggers, who faced only the most token and tepid opposition from the Jellyfish Party (née Democrats), then in the minority.

In dissenting from Sentelle and Raymond, Judge Judith W. Rogers made the salient point that Congress actually doesn't have the power to eviscerate the 800-year-old doctrine of habeas corpus, except in the most extreme cases of internal rebellion or foreign invasion. Although of course an argument could be made that the United States has been in the throes of an insurrection for more than six years following the coup d'etat that brought loser Bush and his gang to power in December 2000, it's not likely that the Administration would support this position in court. But in any case, Congress certainly exceeded its authority in gutting habeas corpus just on the say-so of the power-drunk goober in the White House.

There is a simple remedy to the situation. With the Jellyfish now in narrow control of Congress, they could pass laws restoring habeas corpus rights to Bush's zeks, and repeal or revamp the Reichstaggers' MCA. As the Post notes, bills to this effect have already been offered in the Senate. One assumes that the Jellyfish can muster enough energy to approve the measures – if they haven't completely spent themselves on the exhausting effort of failing to pass a toothless, spineless, gutless, non-binding resolution tut-tutting over Bush's murderous "surge," that is. Bush will doubtless veto any move to tamper with his beloved MCA, but at least the "will of the Congress" argument in favor of gulags and tyranny will no longer apply when the case finally reaches the Supreme Court.

So we'll soon see if the Jellyfish can develop even the slightest hint of spine – or if they will once again quiver and wiggle and run away at the Reichstaggers' perverted propaganda assertions that the defense of liberty, law and justice, not to mention the national honor, is tantamount to "coddling terrorists."
More from this author:
Immaculate Conception: A Squirt in the White House (13983 Hits)
George W. Bush's innumerable sycopants like to potray him as a down-to-earth man of the people: a man's man, tough and fearless, a good-ole-boy...
Thunder on the Mountain: The Murderers of Democracy (11957 Hits)
“Shame on your greed, shame on your wicked schemes. I tell you this right now, I don’t give a damn about your dreams.” -- Bob Dylan,...
War in Heaven: Woodward's Book and the Establishment Insurgency (12844 Hits)
Bob Woodward has long been the voice of the American Establishment – or of certain quadrants of it, at any rate. When Richard Nixon's...
Swing Blades: Don Rumsfeld Bats Both Ways (11269 Hits)
In February 2003, I wrote a column for the Moscow Times detailing Don Rumsfeld's personal – and profitable – connection with North Korea's...
Red October: Killing the Truth in Moscow (11895 Hits)
I. Early October can be dismal in Moscow. The short, harsh summer is over, the brief and beautiful refreshment of September has passed,...
Related Articles:
Bush's Middle East Strategy, and Presidency, Lie in Ruins as Republicans Scurry Away (9718 Hits)
by Dave Lindorff Well, so much for Iraqi “sovereignty.” So much too for "staying the course" and for "fighting the terrorists...
Behind Bush's Nuclear Gift to Terrorism (9379 Hits)
by Chris Floyd I am now writing a piece for Truthout.org on the wider ramifications of the Bush Administration's lunatic dumping of a...
Armagideon Time: Bush's Nuclear Folly and the National Security Lie (15119 Hits)
Written by Chris Floyd This story is appearing today at Truthout.org. "The Bush Faction's remaining claim to political...
Escalation and Expansion: Bush's "Great Leap Forward" Into Hell (6231 Hits)
The outlines of Bush's "New Way Forward" or "Great Leap Forward" or "Long Walk Off a Short Pier" in Iraq is now fairly...


Add this page to your favorite Social Bookmarking websites
Trackback(0)
Comments (1)add comment

a guest said:

0
...
While it is true that the Democrats could, ostensibly, "pass laws restoring habeas corpus rights to Bush's zeks," such laws would be vetoed by Bush, and since the Democrats do not have enough votes to override a veto, such laws would likely remain symbolic gestures. It may be too late for congressional Democrats to change the situation. The sad part is, the Democrats were in a position to stop MCA's passage in the Senate and thus kill the bill even before they gained control of Congress. Alas, they chose not to. Jellyfish indeed! So, the "zeks" will likely have to wait for the Supreme Court to consider the case. - MF, Providence, RI
 
February 24, 2007
Votes: +0

Write comment
smaller | bigger

busy
 

adsense

Top