The first by-lined piece I ever had in a newspaper dealt with the rise of political parties in Italy that proudly claimed descent from the Fascists of Benito Mussolini. This was almost 30 years ago, when memories of the Fascist era in Italy and Germany were still relatively fresh; one didn't have to be very old – hardly middle-aged – to remember growing up under those regimes or else being touched by their shadow in one way or another. And of course, the Fascist regimes in Spain and Portugal had only ended a few years before the article appeared. So the emergence of openly neo-Fascist mainstream parties in Italy – the birthplace of the movement – was a genuine shock in those days.
It's not shocking anymore, of course. For the past 14 years, Italian politics has been dominated b y a Fascist-aligned bloc led by sleazy oligarch Silvio Berlusconi. A capsule description of the dubious neo-Duce that I wrote five years ago for the Bergen Record – on the occasion of Berlusc oni's visit to the Crawford ranch of his good friend, sleazy oligarch George W. Bush – is still apt today:
Berlusconi is Italy's richest man, a media mogul who now controls 90 percent of the nati on's broadcast media and much of its print media – newspapers, magazines, and book publishing – as well Italy's top sports team, the nation's biggest financial services firm and a vast portfolio of other holdings. His first term in office ended in a welter of corruption indictments; his second has been marked by heavy-handed media manipulation and a shocking use of his parliame ntary majority to craft laws exempting him and his cronies from ongoing prosecutions and looming investigations.
He rules Italy through a right-wing coalition that includes a party which proclaims itself the "successor" to fascist dictator Benito Mussolini's sinister faction. He has flatly reneged on earlier promises to divest himself of his media holdings, while conducting a relentless campaign aimed at undermining the authority of Italy's judicial system, a bulwark of the nation's ever-turbulent democratic system. He has sacked journalists from Italy's state television network for criticizing his government – an act of free speech that Berlusconi called "criminal."
Berlusconi was turfed out of office in 2006,
but returned to power this year at the head of his most hard-line
coalition yet. And these days – in our "changed" post-9/11 world, when
Western governments have embraced aggression, authoritarianism and the
adoration of raw power as never before – there is no need for
Berlusconi's blackshirts to sugarcoat their Fascist proclivities. Yet
even though we have learned to expect the worst from our degraded
democracies (and are rarely disappointed), it still comes as something
of a shock to see Italy reviving one of Fascism's most brutal policies
– the official demonization of an entire ethnic group – against one of
the movement's most ravaged historical targets: the Gypsies. Seamus Milne reports in the Guardian:
At
the heart of Europe, police have begun fingerprinting children on the
basis of their race - with barely a murmur of protest from European
governments. Last week, Silvio Berlusconi's new rightwing Italian
administration announced plans to carry out a national registration of
all the country's estimated 150,000 Gypsies - Roma and Sinti people -
whether Italian-born or migrants. Interior minister and leading light
of the xenophobic Northern League, Roberto Maroni, insisted that taking
fingerprints of all Roma, including children, was needed to "prevent
begging" and, if necessary, remove the children from their parents.
The ethnic fingerprinting drive is part of a broader crackdown on
Italy's three-and-a-half million migrants, most of them legal, carried
out in an atmosphere of increasingly hysterical rhetoric about crime
and security. But the reviled Roma, some of whose families have been in
Italy since the middle ages, are taking the brunt of it. The aim is to
close 700 Roma squatter camps and force their inhabitants out of the
cities or the country. In the same week as Maroni was defending his
racial registration plans in parliament, Italy's highest appeal court
ruled that it was acceptable to discriminate against Roma on the
grounds that "all Gypsies were thieves", rather than because of their
"Gypsy nature".
Official roundups and forced closures of Roma camps have been
punctuated with vigilante attacks. In May, rumours of an abduction of a
baby girl by a Gypsy woman in Naples triggered an orgy of racist
violence against Roma camps by thugs wielding iron bars, who torched
caravans and drove Gypsies from their slum homes in dozens of assaults,
orchestrated by the local mafia, the Camorra. [More on the Camorra's
increasing symbiosis with the state here.]
The response of Berlusconi's government to the firebombing and ethnic
cleansing? "That is what happens when Gypsies steal babies," shrugged
Maroni; while fellow minister and Northern League leader Umberto Bossi
declared: "The people do what the political class isn't able to do."
This, it should be recalled, is taking place in a state that under
Benito Mussolini's fascist dictatorship played a willing part in the
Holocaust, during which more than a million Gypsies are estimated to
have died as "sub-humans" alongside the Nazi genocide perpetrated
against the Jews. The first expulsions of Gypsies by Mussolini took
place as early as 1926. Now the dictator's political heirs, the
"post-fascist" National Alliance, are coalition partners in
Berlusconi's government. In case anyone missed that, when the
Alliance's Gianni Alemanno was elected mayor of Rome in April, his
supporters gave the fascist salute chanting "Duce" (equivalent to the
German "Führer") and Berlusconi enthused: "We are the new Falange" (the
Spanish fascist party of General Franco).
As Milne notes, this Fascist revanche has not drawn a single protest
from the leaders of the "free world." Indeed, they welcomed Berlusconi
back with open arms to the gilded circle of G-8 supremos last week. Bush was the most enthusiastic
of all, greeting his old friend and partner in war crime with
enthusiastic shouts of "Amigo!" (Well, it's a foreign word anyway, if
not quite Italian), then commiserating with him over Berlusconi's
continuing criminal indictments (which, once again, he is using state
powers to try to squirm out of). “I read the courts are after you
again,” the American lawbreaker told the Italian sleaze merchant. “It’s
unbelievable. I’ve never seen anything like it. Constantly after you.”
(One can only hope that relentless prosecutors will be "constantly
after" Bush in the years to come.)
II.
But
Milne makes a further point. The rise of neo-fascism in Italy, and
elsewhere, is tied to the collapse — or rather the surrender — of
center-left parties to the pernicious doctrines of the Right.
Everywhere, these parties — - Democrats in America, Labour in the UK,
various Social Democrats throughout Europe – have turned themselves
into pale copies of conservative parties, adopting policies that have
degraded society, destroyed communities, entrenched injustice, rewarded
greed, poisoned the earth, embraced militarism and aggression,
inflicted vast suffering on developing nations (through the
straightjacket of "market reforms," i.e., corporate-crony welfare),
subverted democracy, diminished liberty and gutted the very notion of
the common good.
[Yet we are being too kind in calling this process a "surrender." As Arthur Silber has pointed out
many times, the Democrats – and New Labour and other craven centre-left
parties – have embraced the Right's agenda of elitist domination,
militarism and scorn for the common good because they agree with it.
Any figures with genuinely "progressive" views have been winnowed out
or marginalized by the big money machines that run the parties. Such
people are always a minority amongst the self-interested factions who
vie for domination over a nation's affairs, of course. But there used
to be a more substantial minority of such folks in U.S. politics, with
enough leverage to sometimes affect national policy and even score some
successes. But this strain has been almost completely bred out, as we
have seen in the latest Democratic Congress – the most reviled and
unpopular Congress in American history.]
Back to Milne:
…the
same phenomena can be seen to varying degrees all over Europe, where
racist and Islamophobic parties are on the march: take the far right
Swiss People's party, which on Tuesday succeeded in collecting enough
signatures to force a referendum on banning minarets throughout the
country. In Britain, as Peter Oborne's Channel 4 film on Islamophobia
this week underlined, a mendacious media and political campaign has fed
anti-Muslim hostility and violence since the 2005 London bombings -
just as hostility to asylum seekers was whipped up in the 1990s. The
social and democratic degeneration now reached by Italy can happen
anywhere in the current climate.
Italy has a
further lesson for Britain and the rest of Europe. Berlusconi's
election victory in April was built on the collapse of confidence in
the centre-left government of Romano Prodi, which stuck to a narrow
neoliberal programme and miserably failed to deliver to its own voters.
Meanwhile, centre-left politicians such as Walter Veltroni, the former
mayor of Rome, pandered to, rather than challenged, the xenophobic
agenda of the rightwing parties - tearing down Gypsy camps himself and
absurdly claiming last year that 75% of all crime was committed by
Romanians (often confused with Roma in Italy).
What was needed instead, as in the case of other countries experiencing
large-scale immigration, was public action to provide decent housing
and jobs, clamp down on exploitation of migrant workers and support
economic development in Europe's neighbours. That opportunity has now
been lost, as Italy is gripped by an ominous and retrograde spasm. The
persecution of Gypsies is Italy's shame - and a warning to us all.
In the current U.S. presidential campaign, we can see this dynamic of
center-left collaboration with the Right – which has been going on for
almost a quarter-century in America – playing itself out once again.
Barack Obama's "surge" to the Right – as exemplified by his vote for the tyrannical FISA measure
– is just another iteration of this process. Likewise, his embrace of
the Terror War; true, he wants to do it more "efficiently," and perhaps
add a few more targets – in Pakistan, say – but he still wants to do
it. He makes no bones about continuing this militarist project which
has already killed hundreds of thousands of innocent people, bankrupted
the national treasury, and is now – through the Terror War oil price
spike – strangling the entire national economy. All of this –
especially the Terror War's continuing brutalization and coarsening of
the national ethos – is meet food for neo-fascism to feed upon.
And it's already gorging itself in its ancestral homeland. Rounding up
Gypsy children, fingerprinting them, driving them from their homes,
applauding pogroms — as Faulkner said, the past is never dead; it's not
even past.