FBI documents obtained by a congressional committee indicate that Vice
President Dick Cheney may have authorized his former deputy to leak the
identity of covert CIA operative Valerie Plame Wilson.
In a June 3 letter sent to Attorney General Michael Mukasey, Rep. Henry
Waxman, Democratic chairman of the House Oversight and Government
Reform Committee, called on the Justice Department to release
transcripts of interviews that Special Prosecutor Patrick Fitzgerald
conducted with President George W. Bush and Cheney about the leak of
Plame's identity.
Waxman said the Justice Department has turned over to his committee
redacted transcripts of interviews that federal investigators conducted
with former White House political adviser Karl Rove and Cheney's former
chief of staff I. Lewis "Scooter" Libby.
According to those transcripts, Libby told federal investigators that
Cheney may have told him to leak Plame's association with the CIA to
reporters, Waxman said in the letter to Mukasey.
"In his interview with the FBI, Mr. Libby stated that it was ‘possible’
that Vice President Cheney instructed him to disseminate information
about Ambassador [Joseph] Wilson's wife to the press. This is a
significant revelation and, if true, a serious matter. It cannot be
responsibly investigated without access to the Vice President's FBI
interview," Waxman wrote.
Waxman's office would not release copies of the Libby-Rove transcripts
or describe the contents in any detail. Fitzgerald's investigative
interviews with Bush and Cheney -- asking how much knowledge the
President and Vice President had about the Plame leak -- have not been
disclosed.
The scandal revolves around actions taken in June and July of 2003 when
Rove, Libby and other administration officials leaked information to
reporters aimed at discrediting Ambassador Wilson, who had challenged
the truthfulness of Bush’s pre-invasion claims that Iraq had purchased
yellowcake uranium from Niger.
Durinng the investigation, it was revealed that Bush authorized
portions of a classified National Intelligence Estimate about Iraq’s
alleged WMD to be disseminated to select reporters as part of the
anti-Wilson campaign. Cheney dispatched Libby on that mission.
However, it is still unknown whether Libby was authorized to pass on
information about Plame’s work at the CIA or whether he did that on his
own. Other administration officials, including Deputy Secretary of
State Richard Armitage and Rove, also served as sources for journalists
on Plame’s identity as a CIA officer.
Right-wing columnist Robert Novak blew Plame’s cover on July 14, 2003,
in an article suggesting that Plame had helped arrange her husband’s
trip to Africa as some kind of junket.
Wilson, a diplomat who had served in Iraq and Africa, was selected by
the CIA’s non-proliferation office, where Plame worked, to travel to
Niger in early 2002 to examine the Iraq-yellowcake allegations. Wilson
returned to the United States and reported to CIA officials that the
claims appeared to have no merit, a finding that matched with inquiries
from other U.S. officials.
Nevertheless, in January 2003, seeking to dramatize the need for
invading Iraq, President Bush cited the Niger claims in his State of
the Union speech. That set the stage for Wilson to begin criticizing
the misuse of this intelligence. Initially, Wilson avoided giving all
the details about his role but finally went fully public in a New York
Times op-ed on July 6, 2003.
That, in turn, prompted an intensified White House campaign against
Wilson leading to Novak’s article. With Plame's cover blown and her spy
network endangered, the CIA sought a criminal investigation into the
leak.
Knowing Nothing
As the probe got underway In September 2003, Bush professed to know
nothing about the controversy and publicly called on anyone with
information to step forward. At the time, however, he was withholding
the fact that he had authorized declassification of some secrets about
the Niger uranium issue and had ordered Cheney to arrange for those
secrets to be given to reporters to undermine Wilson’s criticism.
In other words, though Bush knew a great deal about how the anti-Wilson
scheme got started – since he was involved in starting it – he uttered
misleading public statements to conceal the White House role. That was
followed by denials of involvement from Rove and Libby – issued through
then-White House press secretary Scott McClellan.
Fitzgerald indicted Libby in October 2005 on five counts of perjury and
obstruction of justice. In October 2005, I first reported that
Fitzgerald also was investigating whether Cheney played a role in the
leak. I reported, too, that Bush and Cheney discussed Plame prior to
the leak, undercutting Bush's claims some three months later that he
was unaware of nuances of the case.
In February 2007, during closing arguments at Libby's trial, defense
attorney Theodore Wells told jurors that the prosecutors had been
attempting to build a case of conspiracy against the Vice President and
Libby, and that the prosecutors believed Libby may have lied to federal
investigators and to a grand jury to protect Cheney.
In his rebuttal, Fitzgerald told jurors:
"You know what? [Wells] said something here that we're trying to put a
cloud on the Vice President. We'll talk straight. There is a cloud over
the Vice President. He sent Libby off to [meet with former New York
Times reporter] Judith Miller at the St. Regis Hotel. At that meeting -
the two-hour meeting - the defendant talked about the wife [Plame]. We
didn't put that cloud there. That cloud remains because the defendant
obstructed justice and lied about what happened."
The jury convicted Libby of four counts, leading to a sentence of 30
months in jail. However, Bush commuted the sentence to eliminate jail
time and left open the possibility that Libby might get a full pardon
before Bush leaves office.
The way Bush handled Libby’s commutation removed the chief incentive
for Libby to cooperate further with prosecutors (to avoid or reduce his
jail time) and dangled a possible reward down the road if Libby remains
in the administration’s good graces (a full pardon).
Now, according to the transcript cited by Rep. Waxman, it appears that
Libby did tell prosecutors in an earlier interview that it was
“possible” that Cheney did order him to leak Plame’s identity. Waxman
is now pressing to learn what Cheney and Bush said in response to
Fitzgerald's questions about exactly what they did or did not order
their subordinates to do.