In stark contrast, Palestinian Authority President Mahmoud Abbas has
decided to use the Israeli colonial project to his own advantage.
Unlike Abdul-Shafi, who would have challenged Israeli domination with a
collective Palestinian stance of complete cohesion at home and abroad,
Abbas (dubbed a "moderate" and "pragmatic" leader by mainstream media)
opted for the deadly option; he collaborated with the enemy. As
Palestinians in Gaza are murdered at will, completely besieged and
denied the most basic human rights, Abbas's "pragmatic" advisors appear
to have warned him against locking horns with the US and Israel. This
approach overlooks the fact that defeatism has never helped an
oppressed nation recover its lands, its rights and its freedom.
Unfortunately, Abdul-Shafi is no longer there to provide such timely
reminders. The soil of Gaza has finally claimed him; the same way it
claimed the bodies of many resilient Palestinian men and women, young
and old. One can only hope that the spirit of Abdul-Shafi is now free
to wander beyond the enclosed borders, electric fences and blocked
military zones that turned that poor strip of land into a prison
comparable in its isolation to that of Robben Island where Nelson
Mandela and his comrades were held for many years.
As long as Abbas and many in his Fatah Party remain busy concocting
schemes to weaken their rivals in Hamas, and while both parties plot to
fortify their political positions in what must be the most embarrassing
media circus in Palestinian history, Israel no longer faces any serious
resistance. Instead, Israeli politicians now face a different challenge
-- how to widen the gap between divided Palestinians. According to Avi
Issacharoff in Haaretz, the latest question is whether releasing Fatah
leader Marwan Barghouti will help unify all ranks of Fatah, thus
strengthening Abbas and accelerating the break-up of Hamas.
Unlike Abbas, Abdul-Shafi didn't fail his people, despite all of the
hardships he had to endure. He did all that a single person can do on
his own, and more. Shafi's funeral in Gaza reportedly united
Palestinians of all factions. The man had spent much of his energy
achieving this noble goal during his life. At least his death brought
about a fleeting moment of unity, a reminder that such a thing is still
possible.
In his speech at the peace conference in Madrid 31 October 1991,
Abdul-Shafi recited a verse of Mahmoud Darwish: "My homeland is not a
suitcase, and I am no traveller." At the time, my father's home in a
Gaza refugee camp was crowded with neighbours who had come to listen to
the televised speech and they all cried silently in response. I am sure
that those of them still alive have wept again, this time at the
passing of the Palestinian icon of hope whose legacy, like his life,
will always be cherished.
-Ramzy Baroud (ramzybaroud.net) is an author and editor of
PalestineChronicle.com. His work has been published in many newspapers
and journals worldwide. His latest book is The Second Palestinian
Intifada: A Chronicle of a People's Struggle (Pluto Press, London).
er Abdul-Shafi could not have come at a worse time. Bearing in mind the
grim shortcomings of the Palestinian leadership and the lack of any
serious attempt to rectify the situation, the loss of this unique and
iconic leader feels all the more acute.
Here was someone who always managed to transcend factionalism and
religiosity, tribal politics and self-serving ideologies, maintaining
his principles through any external difficulties. He co-founded the
Palestine Liberation Organisation in the 1960s and went on to start the
Palestinian Red Crescent Society in Gaza in the 1970s. The resilient
man led the Palestinian delegation to the Madrid peace talks in 1991
and in 1993 resigned the post after learning from his hotel radio that
Yasser Arafat had reached a secret agreement in Oslo without consulting
the Palestinian negotiators in Spain. Abdul-Shafi told me, in the first
interview I had with him, that learning of Arafat's secret deal from
the media was a particularly embarrassing moment for him.
In the same interview in 2002, Abdul-Shafi also spoke at length about
the Palestinian uprising, talks with Israel, internal corruption and
division, democracy and more. Then aged 83, Abdul-Shafi displayed the
spirit of an idealistic young fighter with unswerving vision, while
also demonstrating the wisdom borne of five decades of selfless
struggle and steadfastness. For him, despair was never an option.
Internal unity, democracy, resistance on all fronts and dialogue on an
equal basis were his ultimate goals. He seemed indefatigable, but his
failing health became his most significant enemy as a few years later
he was diagnosed with cancer and on 25 September 2007 he passed away.
I wonder if the ageing worrier knew of the painful details of internal
Palestinian strife, of shameful and mutual crackdowns on media and
freedom of expression in the West Bank and Gaza, and of division at
every turn in Palestinian life. The Palestine Abdul- Shafi left behind
was not the Palestine that he had fought for with astonishing
dedication.
In his fight, Abdul-Shafi was not afraid to speak his mind and
criticise what disrupted the struggle for Palestinian unity and true
sovereignty. He blamed Arafat and his associates for many of the
post-Oslo disasters that had befallen his people, chastising the
Palestinian leadership for capitulating at Oslo, for accepting far less
than his people's rights and aspirations demanded. He refused to take
part in the "democracy" charade which instituted, among other
pretences, a parliament that had no authority, neither to defy Arafat's
will nor Israel's, whose oppressive occupation only intensified after
the "peace agreements" were signed.
Naturally, shortly after being voted into parliament Abdul-Shafi was
the first to quit, lending his support instead to the Palestinian
National Initiative that advocated national unity, democracy and clean
government. He saw clearly that while Palestinians may not be able to
control Israel's actions, they were certainly capable of coordinating
and correcting their own fallouts. This was really all that he asked.
In stark contrast, Palestinian Authority President Mahmoud Abbas has
decided to use the Israeli colonial project to his own advantage.
Unlike Abdul-Shafi, who would have challenged Israeli domination with a
collective Palestinian stance of complete cohesion at home and abroad,
Abbas (dubbed a "moderate" and "pragmatic" leader by mainstream media)
opted for the deadly option; he collaborated with the enemy. As
Palestinians in Gaza are murdered at will, completely besieged and
denied the most basic human rights, Abbas's "pragmatic" advisors appear
to have warned him against locking horns with the US and Israel. This
approach overlooks the fact that defeatism has never helped an
oppressed nation recover its lands, its rights and its freedom.
Unfortunately, Abdul-Shafi is no longer there to provide such timely
reminders. The soil of Gaza has finally claimed him; the same way it
claimed the bodies of many resilient Palestinian men and women, young
and old. One can only hope that the spirit of Abdul-Shafi is now free
to wander beyond the enclosed borders, electric fences and blocked
military zones that turned that poor strip of land into a prison
comparable in its isolation to that of Robben Island where Nelson
Mandela and his comrades were held for many years.
As long as Abbas and many in his Fatah Party remain busy concocting
schemes to weaken their rivals in Hamas, and while both parties plot to
fortify their political positions in what must be the most embarrassing
media circus in Palestinian history, Israel no longer faces any serious
resistance. Instead, Israeli politicians now face a different challenge
-- how to widen the gap between divided Palestinians. According to Avi
Issacharoff in Haaretz, the latest question is whether releasing Fatah
leader Marwan Barghouti will help unify all ranks of Fatah, thus
strengthening Abbas and accelerating the break-up of Hamas.
Unlike Abbas, Abdul-Shafi didn't fail his people, despite all of the
hardships he had to endure. He did all that a single person can do on
his own, and more. Shafi's funeral in Gaza reportedly united
Palestinians of all factions. The man had spent much of his energy
achieving this noble goal during his life. At least his death brought
about a fleeting moment of unity, a reminder that such a thing is still
possible.
In his speech at the peace conference in Madrid 31 October 1991,
Abdul-Shafi recited a verse of Mahmoud Darwish: "My homeland is not a
suitcase, and I am no traveller." At the time, my father's home in a
Gaza refugee camp was crowded with neighbours who had come to listen to
the televised speech and they all cried silently in response. I am sure
that those of them still alive have wept again, this time at the
passing of the Palestinian icon of hope whose legacy, like his life,
will always be cherished.
-Ramzy Baroud (ramzybaroud.net) is an author and editor of
PalestineChronicle.com. His work has been published in many newspapers
and journals worldwide. His latest book is The Second Palestinian
Intifada: A Chronicle of a People's Struggle (Pluto Press, London).